Spoiler
Show
still alive then he should be able to stay alive by growing the same food, presumably even better as he's alone and there's no dust. He mentioned taking two long sleeps so doesn't even need to hang around to watch it grow.
Interstellar
Re: Interstellar
It's not really a plot hole, if the people of earth are
-
funthing29
- 8 1/2
- Posts: 9753
- Joined: Sun Jan 09, 2011 10:30 pm
- Old post count: 0
- Preferred Cinemas: Swiss Cottage, Finchley Road, Hampstead, Belsize Park, West End, Islington, Holloway, Whiteleys, Shepherd's Bush, North Finchley, Hackney, Stratford, 02 + (last resort) Watford & Hatfield
- Location: London
Re: Interstellar
TheyCallMeMrGlass wrote:Oh good point. Have heard of a lot of plot holes people mentioning which I can personally fill with some imagination but your one stumps me!Celini wrote:quite gorgeous on a big screen and 70mm, but I found it unnecessary too long!
way better than gravity
7/10
SpoilerShowWeren't they supposed to have only 2 years of supply?
The guy who stayed in the station when they went exploring the planet with tidal waves spent most of his 23 years awake! How did that work???
So yeah, good plot hole catch, Celini :)SpoilerShowI thought perhaps he could have put him self in hybernation and be awoken when the ship is detected to leave the planet but then he wouldnt look so aged so cant be that.
Spoiler
Show
He said he had "a couple of long sleeps" so I assume that means he went into those machines for extended stretches of time.
"There is no reason anyone would want a computer in their home."
Ken Olson - Chairman of Digital Equipment Corporation, speaking in 1977
Member No. 29 of the "100 free films in 2016" club: 62 seen; 38 to go (40 theatre/shows seen)
70 free films seen in 2015 + 85 theatre/shows
84 free films seen in 2014 (81 different films, 3 repeat viewings) + 119 theatre/shows
126 free films seen in 2013 (121 different films, 5 repeat viewings
121 free films seen in 2012 (115 different films, 6 repeat viewings)
129 free films seen in 2011 (117 different films, 12 repeat viewings)
Ken Olson - Chairman of Digital Equipment Corporation, speaking in 1977
Member No. 29 of the "100 free films in 2016" club: 62 seen; 38 to go (40 theatre/shows seen)
70 free films seen in 2015 + 85 theatre/shows
84 free films seen in 2014 (81 different films, 3 repeat viewings) + 119 theatre/shows
126 free films seen in 2013 (121 different films, 5 repeat viewings
121 free films seen in 2012 (115 different films, 6 repeat viewings)
129 free films seen in 2011 (117 different films, 12 repeat viewings)
-
TheyCallMeMrGlass
- Se7en
- Posts: 3461
- Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 3:55 pm
- Old post count: 0
- Preferred Cinemas: Any London cinema, mainly central or south London.
- Location: London
Re: Interstellar
funthing29 wrote:TheyCallMeMrGlass wrote:Oh good point. Have heard of a lot of plot holes people mentioning which I can personally fill with some imagination but your one stumps me!Celini wrote:quite gorgeous on a big screen and 70mm, but I found it unnecessary too long!
way better than gravity
7/10
SpoilerShowWeren't they supposed to have only 2 years of supply?
The guy who stayed in the station when they went exploring the planet with tidal waves spent most of his 23 years awake! How did that work???
So yeah, good plot hole catch, Celini :)SpoilerShowI thought perhaps he could have put him self in hybernation and be awoken when the ship is detected to leave the planet but then he wouldnt look so aged so cant be that.SpoilerShowHe said he had "a couple of long sleeps" so I assume that means he went into those machines for extended stretches of time.
Spoiler
Show
Oh did he say that? That explains it. I did initially think he would go into hybernation but then he looks like he aged 20 years, I thought their hibernation process prevents the body aging but anyway lets fill that plot hole and assume the body ages in hibernation then :)
My film reviews here . ......My FMUK 2014 ratings.......My FMUK 2011 ratings.......My FMUK 2013 ratings . ......My FMUK 2012 ratings .
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
-
The Sparrow
- 8 1/2
- Posts: 6895
- Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 7:15 pm
- Old post count: 0
Re: Interstellar
He also said
Spoiler
Show
he was worried about them and thought they weren't coming back. So he still spent quite a bit of time outside of hibernation which accounted for him ageing.
Free Films Seen 2016
Jan - 7. Feb - 15. Mar - 39
Apr - 28. May - 41. June - 36
July - 39. Aug - 27. Sept - 42
Oct- 12 and counting. = 286
Jan - 7. Feb - 15. Mar - 39
Apr - 28. May - 41. June - 36
July - 39. Aug - 27. Sept - 42
Oct- 12 and counting. = 286
-
TheyCallMeMrGlass
- Se7en
- Posts: 3461
- Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 3:55 pm
- Old post count: 0
- Preferred Cinemas: Any London cinema, mainly central or south London.
- Location: London
Re: Interstellar
The Sparrow wrote:He also saidSpoilerShowhe was worried about them and thought they weren't coming back. So he still spent quite a bit of time outside of hibernation which accounted for him ageing.
Spoiler
Show
Yeah but as Celini pointed out, they only had two year food supply and two years doesnt really age you as drastically as the poor guy on the ship. So we may still have to assume one ages physically while in hibernation. Unless with the time he had to spare invented a food replicator or something!
My film reviews here . ......My FMUK 2014 ratings.......My FMUK 2011 ratings.......My FMUK 2013 ratings . ......My FMUK 2012 ratings .
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
-
steve9872
- SuperMember
- Posts: 7059
- Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 4:43 pm
- Old post count: 456
- Location: Leeds - 456 posts on old site
Re: Interstellar
TheyCallMeMrGlass wrote:The Sparrow wrote:He also saidSpoilerShowhe was worried about them and thought they weren't coming back. So he still spent quite a bit of time outside of hibernation which accounted for him ageing.SpoilerShowYeah but as Celini pointed out, they only had two year food supply and two years doesnt really age you as drastically as the poor guy on the ship. So we may still have to assume one ages physically while in hibernation. Unless with the time he had to spare invented a food replicator or something!
Spoiler
Show
Professor Matt Damon continued to look young despite being in hibernation for even longer.
Member number 13 of the 100 free films in 2019 club. 
My more realistic target is 80
20 seen so far, Páid for 0
Movie list 2019
29 seen 2018
53 seen 2017
61 seen 2016
86 seen 2015
71 seen 2014
90 seen 2013
77 seen 2012
69 seen 2011
60 seen 2010
Looking forward to in 2019: (Jan) Glass (Feb) (mar) Captain Marvel, (apr) Avengers: Endgame ,(May) (jun) Dark Phoenix, MIB: International (Jul) (aug) The new mutants, (sep) (oct) (nov) Kingsman 3 (dec)
My more realistic target is 80
20 seen so far, Páid for 0
Movie list 2019
29 seen 2018
53 seen 2017
61 seen 2016
86 seen 2015
71 seen 2014
90 seen 2013
77 seen 2012
69 seen 2011
60 seen 2010
Looking forward to in 2019: (Jan) Glass (Feb) (mar) Captain Marvel, (apr) Avengers: Endgame ,(May) (jun) Dark Phoenix, MIB: International (Jul) (aug) The new mutants, (sep) (oct) (nov) Kingsman 3 (dec)
-
TheyCallMeMrGlass
- Se7en
- Posts: 3461
- Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 3:55 pm
- Old post count: 0
- Preferred Cinemas: Any London cinema, mainly central or south London.
- Location: London
Re: Interstellar
steve9872 wrote:TheyCallMeMrGlass wrote:The Sparrow wrote:He also saidSpoilerShowhe was worried about them and thought they weren't coming back. So he still spent quite a bit of time outside of hibernation which accounted for him ageing.SpoilerShowYeah but as Celini pointed out, they only had two year food supply and two years doesnt really age you as drastically as the poor guy on the ship. So we may still have to assume one ages physically while in hibernation. Unless with the time he had to spare invented a food replicator or something!SpoilerShowProfessor Matt Damon continued to look young despite being in hibernation for even longer.
Spoiler
Show
Ha, indeed. Which means we go back to square one with Celini's plot hole...but lets see if we can fill it...how about this: Hibernation can have side effect to some individuals...one symptom being, you look a older when you wake up! So Couper's colleague is allergic to hybernating.
My film reviews here . ......My FMUK 2014 ratings.......My FMUK 2011 ratings.......My FMUK 2013 ratings . ......My FMUK 2012 ratings .
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
Re: Interstellar
.... . -.-. .- -. --. .-. --- .-- ..-. --- --- -..
-
TheyCallMeMrGlass
- Se7en
- Posts: 3461
- Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 3:55 pm
- Old post count: 0
- Preferred Cinemas: Any London cinema, mainly central or south London.
- Location: London
Re: Interstellar
Lol, brilliant! Well done D-Fens, you have solved the "plot hole". Nice touch with the morse code.D-Fens wrote:.... . -.-. .- -. --. .-. --- .-- ..-. --- --- -..
Spoiler
Show
ALthough, still a tiny stretch for he has to wait for the food to grow
My film reviews here . ......My FMUK 2014 ratings.......My FMUK 2011 ratings.......My FMUK 2013 ratings . ......My FMUK 2012 ratings .
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
Do you have a VR headset? If so, maybe we can play a physical sports game or even be sports/fitness partners, hit me up if you keen.
PSN: TheyCallMeTej, Oculus: TheyCallMeTJ
-
steve9872
- SuperMember
- Posts: 7059
- Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 4:43 pm
- Old post count: 456
- Location: Leeds - 456 posts on old site
Re: Interstellar
TranslationD-Fens wrote:.... . -.-. .- -. --. .-. --- .-- ..-. --- --- -..
Spoiler
Show
HECANGROWFOOD
Spoiler
Show
It takes a lot of light to grow plants and I didn't see much along the lines of windows on their spacecraft.
Member number 13 of the 100 free films in 2019 club.
My more realistic target is 80
20 seen so far, Páid for 0
Movie list 2019
29 seen 2018
53 seen 2017
61 seen 2016
86 seen 2015
71 seen 2014
90 seen 2013
77 seen 2012
69 seen 2011
60 seen 2010
Looking forward to in 2019: (Jan) Glass (Feb) (mar) Captain Marvel, (apr) Avengers: Endgame ,(May) (jun) Dark Phoenix, MIB: International (Jul) (aug) The new mutants, (sep) (oct) (nov) Kingsman 3 (dec)
My more realistic target is 80
20 seen so far, Páid for 0
Movie list 2019
29 seen 2018
53 seen 2017
61 seen 2016
86 seen 2015
71 seen 2014
90 seen 2013
77 seen 2012
69 seen 2011
60 seen 2010
Looking forward to in 2019: (Jan) Glass (Feb) (mar) Captain Marvel, (apr) Avengers: Endgame ,(May) (jun) Dark Phoenix, MIB: International (Jul) (aug) The new mutants, (sep) (oct) (nov) Kingsman 3 (dec)